The Black Hole Tragedy 20th June 1756
Siraj-ud-Daullah,
the young, inexperienced and impulsive Nawab of Bengal, was neither
very fond of the Europeans nor of their expansion plans. He was aroused
by the open defiance of his authority by Governor Drake when one of his
messengers was summarily expelled. This aroused the young Nawab who
reached Kolkata on 16
th June, 1756 at the head of a 30000
strong infantry, ably supported by a battery of artillery led by a
detatchment of 25 Europeans and Indo-Portuguese. He camped at the house
of a wealthy Sikh named Amirchand or Umichand, situated at Shimulia
(Shimla area near Manicktala) and adjacent to the Marhatta Ditch. The
major part of Siraj’s brigade crossed the ditch near Sealdaha on 18
th
June, 1756 and the “Battle of Laldighi” was fought. The British army,
positioned on the eastern side of the tank square, was not suitably
geared up to sustain the Nawab’s offensives and consequently submitted
to the forces of the Nawab and drove back to an inner line of defence
around the fort. An informal council was convened by Governor Drake and
the decision to abandon the fort was taken, though how and when still
remained to be known.
The Nawab’s army increased pressure on the English army and the
European women and children were evacuated by boats. Even a few white
men, including Governor Drake, escaped. Finally there remained within
the fort about 170 white men led by J. Z. Holwell, the
Magistrate-Collector of Bengal. Confusion and panic mounted.
Demoralization led to total pandemonium. On the afternoon of June 20
th
1756 Holwell decided to surrender. What followed was the confused
course of events associated in English chronicles with the infamous
“Black Hole Tragedy”. But the European version of the incident is
overtly exaggerated and no authenticity could be attributed to these
accounts, which state that upon the ill fated night, around 146 European
Men were forced into the fort prison, a room measuring about 18’ by
14’10” of whom about 23 came out alive the next day, as observed by
Holwell, who claimed to have been one of the survivors.
This account by Holwell is really questionable, because by no stretch
of imagination could 146 White men be accommodated into a room of the
size of the prison at the Fort William. This theory is corroborated by
the 19
th Century historian name Bholanath Chandra, who tried
to accommodate the same number to lean Bengali men into an enclosure of
about the same size (18’ by 15’) as the ill reputed room.
Authentic sources pointed out that there could not probably have been
146 white men in Kolkata, that evening, because after his victory Siraj
allowed many Europeans to escape. Even Holwell, as he himself admitted,
was also given the chance.
Authenticity has been attributed to the account that put the number
at 60 out of which not more than twenty emerged alive the next morning.
What happened was definitely unfortunate, but the European accounts of
the event were grossly exaggerated. Historians unearthed reports that
showed that Siraj himself, probably, did not have a direct bearing upon
the incident. It was probably the result of over enthusiasm on the part
of his men in carrying out certain orders from the Nawab.
Other European Accounts of the Event
Stanley Wolpert argues that only 64 people were imprisoned and 21
survived. D.L. Prior argues that 43 members of the garrison were dead or
missing for reasons other than suffocation and shock, while Busteed
argues that, because so many non-combatants were present in the fort
when it fell, the number who died cannot be stated with any
precision. Regarding responsibility, Holwell believed that it “was the
result of revenge and resentment in the breasts of the lower
Jemmaatdaars [sergeants], to whose custody we were delivered, for the
number of their order killed during the siege.” Wolpert concurs and
argues that Siraj did not order it and was not informed about it.